Feedback

3C Scribe

Clear, concise, and compelling writing and editing

by Andra Paitz

Reid Minnich (author of the The Koinobi Trilogy)

 

"I thought I didn’t need an editor. I'm pretty good at punctuation and spelling, and I thought several beta readers and a grammar check program would suffice. If that is all you think you need, then you are where I was at before I met Andra. She wasn’t selling me on her services, just chit-chatting about our books at a writer’s group social. Her insights into plot and character development singled her out as someone who was accomplished at writing. I was looking for beta readers at the time and Andra volunteered.

 

To be clear, I have had many beta readers. Some of them are Grammar Nazis, and some of them are good with plot and character development. Andra's low-effort beta of my book pointed out miscues, ambiguous statements, character contradictions, and plot holes that dozens of beta readers had missed. Then Andra suggested she could do a real edit. The end result was a highly polished story that was more enjoyable for Grammar Nazis and pleasure readers alike."

 

 

Elaine Leung-Wolf (author of At Stage Ⅳ’s Door, a work in progress)

 

"Andra’s feedback was insightful, clear, and informative. As a first-time author and memoirist, her ability to explain the reasons behind her suggestions in concrete ways has helped me to improve the quality of my writing. I feel that she gets right into the crux of the issue whether it is content, sentence structure, or word choice. Andra was also generous with her time, giving me an overview of her editorial process.

 

As a conservatory-level instructor of piano, I appreciate both the detail and the depth to which Andra feels the pacing and structure of what we worked on; there are many similarities to a musical composition. I am very much looking forward to working with Andra as I complete my first draft."

 

Stacy Bender (author of the Sav'ine series)

 

"When Andra Paitz agreed to edit Emerald Tears, I was amazed at what she found. I had run the manuscript by several beta readers, an editing program, and an audio program. So I wasn’t expecting much. Not only did she find more spelling and punctuation errors, but a few plot holes. I’m glad she also had a few suggestions on how to fix them...

 

[Andra's editing concerns]

The first, was that one of my main characters might turn off a few readers before they got to the ‘why’ of the way he acted.

The second, was a few small historical references that were a year or two outside my chosen timeline.

The third, was the urban myth of killing a person by shattering their nose and sending splinters into the brain.

 

That’s just what I remember off the top of my head. Good editors like Andra Paitz are hard to find."

Pamela Holdren (author of Angel's Kiss, book one of the Angelique Black series)

 

"Finding reliable beta readers is daunting, but finding a beta reader as comprehensive and helpful as Andra is rare. Andra was a godsend. As a new novelist, I benefited immensely from her experience and expertise in improving my manuscript and my craft in general. Timely, yet thorough, she offered an abundance of insightful feedback regarding content with emphasis on plot and character development, pacing, and forming that ever-so-important connection with my readers (and managed to do so with good humor). I will definitely seek her out in the future and enthusiastically recommend her services to any writer looking for an honest critique of their work."

 

Here's your reward for scrolling all the way to the bottom: a picture of my ink collection.